10 Alternatives to Spanking

 

Getty Images

Spanking isn't necessarily something a parent consciously chooses. Most often, it happens when grownups lose their cool, get worked up or feel desperate. Dad may give little Tommy a whack because he's already asked him three times to turn off the television. Or when four-year-old Johnny runs across the road, his mom may spank him and warn, "Don't you ever, ever run into the street again." All parents know how profoundly annoying it can be when their little one doesn't listen to them. Fear has the same effect: "Oh my gosh, what if Johnny isn't so lucky the next time he runs into the street?" The vast majority of parents have either felt the urge to spank, or have given their child a pat, whack or smack at one time or another.

In fact, according to the American Academy of Pediatrics, spanking happens at least once a week in 25 percent of two-parent, middle-class families. Why do so many parents end up spanking their kids? You might assume it's because spanking works. But, in fact, spanking works if, and only if, you look at the short-term. Three-year-old Lucy picked up her toys with lightening-fast speed after her mom gave her a swat on the behind. However, Lucy's teachers need to keep a close eye on her in the playground because she tends to bully the younger kids. What does one have to do with the other?

A crucial 2002 study takes a look at how spanking affects kids. Psychologist Elizabeth Thompson Gershoff of Columbia University's National Center for Children in Poverty analyzed 62 years of collected data, and found that the more often a child is spanked, the greater is the risk of childhood aggression and other antisocial behaviors such as lying, cheating and bullying. Children who are raised with spankings are less likely to learn right from wrong, and are more likely to misbehave behind their parent's backs. One of the pro-spanking mothers in my practice conceded, "My son behaves if I spank him -- but I don't know if he's behaving out of fear or because he's learning to distinguish right from wrong." Clearly, spanking changes a child.

Chime In
Chime in now!
    More to Explore
    Discipline: What method really works? Everyday stresses can be exasperating for parents -- and exhausting for kids. Children inevitably test limits. What should a parent do? Is there a method of discipline that really works? While some parents are not comfortable in the disciplina MORE
    Learning the 10 Ingredients of Conscious Discipline Now that you know how to tune into your toddler and anticipate her needs through H.E.L.P., R&R and T.L.C., it's time to focus on discipline. No matter how adept you become at structuring your toddler's routines and avoiding problem situations, the MORE
    Disciplining a Six-Year-Old Many six year olds are still struggling with issues of control. They find it hard to accept that they cannot do whatever they want to do, whenever they want to do it. But this is an important lesson we must teach them. I think it is very impor MORE
    Hitting: When your toddler hits Your two year old sounds like he is becoming interested in other people. Hitting, pushing and grabbing toys are all ways that toddlers use to try to make contact with others, before they develop other social skills. Your son sounds like he is curious MORE
    Advertisement

    must watch video of the day



    Advertisement