Photo Credit: nbc
It's Jack's birthday, and he's happily settling into his relationship with Avery. That is, until Nancy Donovan returns to announce she's gotten him the best present of all -- a divorce. Jack decides to juggle his two paramours until he can decide which one he wants for the long haul. This undertaking proves increasingly difficult, even for the formidable Mr. Donaghy. In the end, he chooses not to choose just yet.
Meanwhile, Lemon has her own relationship woes. She branches out, joining local singles groups for everything from from dodgeball to line dancing (and cheese tasting, obvs) -- but to no avail. It probably doesn't help that she has no qualms hurling dodgeballs at her crushes' heads.