"Joy to the World" all the boys and girls... got together to sing -- before some of them were swimming with the fishes in the deep blue sea. For the second week, America voted for their favorites and four contestants came up short. Calling all American Idol hopefuls now and for those to come... If this week was any indication, don't sing Nina Simone's "Feeling Good." Two different contestants, two different genders, two different renditions... It didn't matter. Leslie and AJ, you are what you sing...It's a new dawn, it's a new day, it's a new life... They were half of the four who got the least amount of votes. Alaina and Nick make up the other half. 32 million votes came in this week. Did you vote for your favorite? If you're sad to see someone go tonight, that's a lesson learned. Every vote counts.