American Idol Results: The Wrong Song

It all came down to the wrong song for four contestants this week.
Jason Yeagar, Robbie Carrico, Alexandrea Lushington and Alaina Whitaker all picked the wrong song.  And didn't showcase the best of what they have to offer.     Here's a broken down Jason Yegar, getting consoled by Paula.   Yeager is a good guy and a really good singer.  It looks like his nerves got the best of him in this competition.  And he also needed to find that perfect song... which he never did.     Something Yeager said that impressed me was how he was trying to find "the song" to break out his guitar skills.  I liked that he didn't just pick any song to show off with... or every song (which gets old too).  He was strategically planning what he was going to do.    A good lesson learned here though is -- you can't wait.  Every week should be treated as if it's your last.  

Alexandrea Lushington would have still been alive... had she picked the right song.  She was one of Randy's favorite of the bunch.  She had a very cool way about her and was a lot of fun.  Paula is right though, It's not the end.  "It's never the end on this show.  It's the beginning of your career so rock it."     

Robbie Carrico rocked it for the last time on the Idol stage.  This week we saw him get a little too arrogant with the whole "get used to it" crack.  Simon said it all comes down to authenticity and "the public saw what we saw.  It never felt real."

But I have to add, Simon, if it never "felt real" why would he make it this far? 

Alaina Whitaker says she couldn't sing herself off the show... she was too emotional and embarrassed. 

But after a little prodding.. she grabbed that mic...hey!  The song got off to a rocky start, but by the end she was back to her hammy self.

Big time guest artists were announced for the second annual Idol Gives Back show -- like Snoop Dogg!  Other musicians include: Smiley-Miley Cyrus (aka Hanna Montana), Mariah Carey, AI season 5's Chris Daughtry, and season 4's Carrie Underwood.  Actors like Brad Pitt and Reese Witherspoon are also getting involved.  

Who's buzzing about what out there?  Does anyone have any American Idol scoop they'd like to share?
Like this? Want more?
Connect with Us
Follow Our Pins

Yummy recipes, DIY projects, home decor, fashion and more curated by iVillage staffers.

Follow Our Tweets

The very dirty truth about fashion internships... DUN DUN @srslytheshow

On Instagram

Behind-the-scenes pics from iVillage.

Best of the Web