Are Preschool Kids Too Young to Be Diagnosed with Depression?

 

Getty Images

A recent New York Times Magazine article about kids as young as age 2 or 3 getting diagnosed with clinical depression has plenty of people talking. The story describes a 5-year-old boy, nicknamed Kiran, who never seems to find joy in the things preschool kids do, like playing with Legos or going to children's museums and amusement parks. Kiran's parents are told he has "preschool depression," a.k.a. early-onset depression.

It's a fairly new concept for kids this age to be considered clinically depressed, but more research is being done -- studies are happening at places like the Early Emotional Development Program at Washington University Medical School in St. Louis. Some experts think that diagnosing depression at such a young age could be extremely beneficial to kids, since brain makeup is still so malleable and treatment (now, usually "play therapy") has the potential to produce more dramatic results. But others worry that preschool depression could become overdiagnosed, since young kids tend to have wide-ranging emotions and some parents could mistakenly think something's wrong when their child is really completely healthy.

Do you think diagnosing depression at preschool-age could help kids? Or hurt them? Chime in below!

Like This? Read These:
- Identifying Depression in Kids
- Depression and Teens: Your Top 8 Questions Answered
- Depression in Children and Teens

Chime In
Do you think diagnosing depression at preschool-age could help kids? Or hurt them?
Chime in now!
    More to Explore
    Community Roundup: Should Family Size Be Limited to Two Kids? - iVillage Read These: -Did the Duggars Push the Discovery Channel Gunman Over the Edge? - Are Preschool Kids Too Young to Be Diagnosed with Depression? - Having a Sister Can Protect ... MORE
    Identifying depression in children - iVillage It can attack children as young as four or five as well as ... aches, headaches, and dizziness; bedwetting, nightmares and aggressive behavior. If you suspect your child is ... MORE
    Reese Witherspoon & Jim Toth Take the Kids on Their Honeymoon - iVillage use search title|... to Two Kids? -iVillage Read These: -Did the Duggars Push the Discovery Channel Gunman Over the Edge? - Are Preschool Kids Too Young to Be Diagnosed with Depression? MORE
    Depression in Children and Teens - iVillage use search title|In some children, depression seems to be inherited. How is depression diagnosed? ... for children with depression to have other problems too, such ... For young children, ... MORE
    Bipolar Disorder - Symptoms - iVillage Signs of Pregnancy; Fertility; Celebrations; Pregnancy Tests ... may have bipolar disorder with mixed symptoms, in ... This information does not replace the advice of a doctor. MORE
    Bipolar Disorder - Topic Overview - iVillage The Stuff We Love Blog; Princess Gift Ideas; Gear Guides -- what should I buy? ... This topic discussesbipolar disorder in adults. If you are concerned that your ... MORE
    Advertisement

    'My Best Idea' Clip of the Day



    Advertisement