The Art of Breaking Up Gently but Firmly

ON Jan 1, 1999 at 12:00PM

chime in now

Dear Sherry:

My boyfriend of two months is a terrific guy, but I'm just not in love and I know I won't fall in love. Unfortunately, he says he loves me and wants to get serious. What's the kindest way to break up with him?

Cindy

Question:
ABOUT THE EXPERT

Sherry Amatenstein

Sherry is the author of The Q&A Dating Book and Love Lessons from Bad Breakups. She has taught dating seminars, appeared as an expert... Read more

Dear Cindy:

Do it gently and quickly. Say something like, "You're a wonderful guy and I really enjoy being with you. But, since I don't think we have what it takes for the long run, I care about you too deeply to lead you on."

Here are three don'ts:

  • Don't make him feel he did something wrong that turned you off.
  • Don't make him feel that there is something wrong with his physical or emotional makeup that renders him unlovable.
  • Don't give him false hope that you'll change your mind.

And a very important do:

  • Do treat him with respect and answer his questions as honestly -- but diplomatically -- as possible. That way he can get closure.

Breaking up is never fun for either party, but you've got the easier job. Anyone who says it's more painful to leave than to be left is either in denial or a blatant liar. He deserves your kindness and compassion.

Answer:
Got an answer? Want to see what other moms are saying? Answer Now
Chime In
Chime in now!
    More to Explore
    Pressure and Discharge in Early Third Trimester Dear Heather, Although the feeling of carrying the baby lower is more common with second pregnancies or beyond, the extreme amount of pressure and the vaginal discharge would lead me to recommend that you get an appointment as soon as possible MORE
    Pregnancy: Is lower abdominal pain normal in early pregnancy? I am assuming that you have had an exam to confirm that your pregnancy is normal -- and not an ectopic pregnancy. If you have not yet had an exam, it is very important to get in as soon as possible. If all else is normal and you are not runnin MORE
    Inguinal Hernia: How Do I Relieve the Pain? I'm not surprised that your search yielded few if any comments about hernias during pregnancy. The incidence of inguinal hernias in pregnancy is one in a 1,000; this is much more common in males than in females due to anatomical factors. There MORE
    Severe Pelvic Pain: Pubic Symphysis Separation? I am so sorry that this pain has intruded upon your pregnancy and your life. Such pain is never normal, and my initial advice is to seek another opinion until you find our what is wrong. Despite the fact that your own doctors sound supportive, I think MORE
    Pregnancy: Is Early Pregnancy Spotting Normal? Spotting during early pregnancy can be very normal. Sometimes it is accompanied by low back pain and cramping in the lower abdomen. The endometrium builds up a thick bed of blood vessels and as the 'blastocyst' implants, some blood i MORE
    Labor: What Does Baby's Station Mean? The concept of 'station' denotes the degree of engagement of the fetal head as it navigates the maternal pelvis. Station is the relationship of the presentng part to an imaginary line drawn between the ischial spines of the pelvis. The ischi MORE
    Search over 3000 Q&As
    Find advice from experts and moms on commonly asked questions.
    Need Advice?
    Get answers from iVillage experts and other moms just like you!
    ASK YOUR QUESTION
    Question Details
    Subject
    1. Pick a subject:
    More Q&As

    See All Q&As

    Advertisement
    what else is on your mind today
    Connect with 1,039,394 members just like you
    Share your knowledge, ask questions.
    Join Now

    See All Pregnancy Boards

    What Moms Are Reading

    See All What Moms Are Reading

    Advertisement