Your boyfriend has been on a date before in his life and you're creeped out? I really don't understand why you'd feel weird about that. I guess if it were me I'd be amused at best, but to feel strange about it and dwell on that feeling, that's too much.
"I guess I can understand him being new to the state back then, and wanting to meet people, but still! ""But still" what?
I can't for the life of me get why this is a big deal, it was one date. All they did was get to know one another well enough to decide they weren't even going to go on date #2.
I agree with the other member.