I joined an online dating website about a month ago.
You should definitely meet both & then decided--and actually you don't have to decide after the first date.
Good advice from Musiclover. Just wanted to add: Oftentimes when you meet someone via OLD, the picture you had of them through emails is not accurate when you meet. Sometimes you can have what you feel is great chemistry in emails or on the phone, but then you meet and it fizzles. Anyway, I'm telling you this because I think you should meet both. You really won't know until you meet them.
Also, there's no need for you to tell them that you are going to meet another guy. They don't need to know that.
Best of luck.
One generally doesn't date just one person when you place an ad on an online dating site.
You should go out with them both!!! That's the beauty of online dating..options!
I met two guys in one weekend recently.