Nick and Avery giggle in her bed. They talk about making gingerbread men and snowman pancakes. Nick goes to the kitchen and spots a dog tag with the name 'Dylan McAvoy'. He hides it before Avery appears. At the Abbott house, Jack tells Phyllis he's glad she's there. He gifts her with an ornament that was his grandmother's on his father's side. She feels awkward. He says she's  and notes her loyalty, kindness, and patience. Jack puts on music and they dance. They reflect back on being married, but then Phyllis regrets bringing it up. Jack's just glad they remained close. They kiss. Phyllis decides it wasn't a good idea - neither of them is ready for this. She tearfully says goodbye. Jack wipes away tears too, and pours a drink.