At the apartment Michael and Starr wake up together. They discuss holiday plans and she remembers Johnny wanted to tell her something. She tells Michael that Johnny was distraught but not about what. Michael says he has to see his father, and replies he hasn’t talked to either since before Christmas. He thinks each probably thinks he spent the holiday with the other. On the hospital roof Spinelli sees Ellie smoking. She’s upset about breaking up. Spinelli says he was dumped. Ellie argues about being stranded at Sonny’s and the Giambetti brothers ogling her and talking about ghosts. Spinelli says she shouldn’t worry about Maxie. Ellie asks if it was okay to spoil her evening and wonders why Spinelli left the party to be with Maxie. Spinelli begs her for another chance and a New Year’s to make it up. She tells him they both have to be sure. Spinelli suggests they meet on the hospital roof at midnight if they both decide to continue as a couple. They seal the deal with a handshake and Ellie leaves.