Photo Credit: Frederick Breedon/Wireimage
"She actually gave us all wrap gifts," said Salling, who scored an old-fashioned telephone receiver that plugs into a cell phone.
In addition to being generous, Salling, 28, called out Paltrow for having a great sense of humor. "She's very funny," he added. "She put up with all of our questions about (husband Chris Martin's band) Coldplay."
Now there's rumblings that Glee's executive producer Ryan Murphy may have Paltrow back on the show to reprise her role -- and to maybe get a little romantic with Matthew Morrison's Mr. Schuester.
Would you like to see Gwyneth Paltrow reprise her role on Glee? Chime in below!