Has the new baby sparked sibling rivalry?

We have a three-year-old and a newborn. Our older daughter has been very loving with her sister; however, she is suddenly showing signs of insecurity. She always wants to be in her room by herself and won't let me touch any of her toys. She is at home with me all the time, except for a ballet class. Could she need friends?


Gayle Peterson

Gayle Peterson, PhD, is a family therapist specializing in prenatal and family development. She is a clinical member of the Association... Read more

Your daughter is expressing positive feelings toward her new sibling, while guarding her turf, too. It is natural at this age that she would protect her things and want to hang around inside the home during this period of acclimation.

Your description does not paint a picture of insecurity, but rather one of attentiveness to change. Do not worry, these are signs of healthy adjustment!

It is possible that your three-year-old would benefit from new friendships at this time. However, pushing her toward others before she has fully adapted to her new environment with the baby, or expecting her to begin sharing her toys with others, might just backfire. Take it slow. Consider inviting a little friend over for a play date, perhaps from her ballet class if she shows interest. But be aware that your anxiety may be emotionally charged, if you feel guilty about not being able to spend the kind of time with her that you did in the past.

It is likely that some part of your anxiety is an expression of your own postpartum adjustment. After all, you have lost some of the time you no doubt enjoyed spending with your daughter and may be missing the one-on-one relationship you once had. Your relationship with your first child has changed irrevocably when you had a second baby. Many mothers feel this adjustment to be more difficult than subsequent children because of the quality of undivided attention you can give one child, which is forever altered when additional members arrive on the family scene.

Your daughter's retreat to her room could be, in part, her way of dealing with the change in the one-on-one attention she used to enjoy from you. Children, too, can experience a kind of "postpartum letdown" with all that is new and different in their lives.

Be proactive in giving her ways to help you and be involved in activities with you and the new baby. Bringing you a diaper, talking and playing with the baby during a diaper change, and organizing activities that keep her in the same room with you can help, such as baking cookies. Or she can draw a picture of her new family while sitting next to you. This may assure her that she is an active participant and irreplaceable member of the new family constellation, despite the changes!

Special time with dad and one-on-one time with mom are definitely in order for your little girl. Let her know that there are periods in the day that she will get your full and undivided attention. A nighttime story, a weekend visit to the library or other activities for just the two of you will further ensure her adjustment as well as your own.

The three months following the birth of a child is termed the postpartum period for a reason. Your hormones are rearranging your body (and moods!), which can make you vulnerable to increased anxiety or even the blues. Let the dust settle, before interpreting your child's changes in a negative light.

Need Advice?
Get answers from iVillage experts and other moms just like you!
Question Details
  1. Pick a subject:
Connect with 1,039,394 members just like you
Share your knowledge, ask questions.