How 'Good Luck, Charlie' Smacks of the Past

 

Disney.com

They say the more things change, the more they stay the same. This has never been more true than in the case of Good Luck, Charlie, The Disney Channel's new monster hit about a nine-month-old kid and her colorful middle-class family.

One of this show's major differences from other Disney "hit-coms" is that both Mom and Dad are present (as opposed to the family dynamic in Hannah Montana, Cory in the House, or Sonny with a Chance). Disney executives said they wanted a show as much about parents as kids to appeal to a family audience, as well as one in which the parents are not "dumber than the kids."

These narrative tweaks are ironically retro. When we were kids, sitcoms almost always featured intact nuclear families (Think: Family, Family Ties and Family Matters). In these families, the parents were almost always smarter than the kids (Think: Howard Cunningham, Heathcliff Huxtable, Mike Brady and Jason Seaver).

And then there's Full House, the 1987-95 sit-com that's even more like Good Luck, Charlie than you might first think. Consider:

Good Luck's Charlie and Full House's Michelle are both nine months old as their shows starts. (Given the Olsens' Hollywood habits, someone please keep an eye on one-year-old Mia Talerico -- she's not even not a twin!)  

Some more TV family math:

Good Luck's not-so-smart PJ = Full House's not-so-smart Jesse
Good Luck's tender man Bob = Full House's tender man Joey
Good Luck's moral leader Amy = Full House's moral leader Danny
Good Luck's oldest child Teddy = Full House's oldest daughter DJ
Good Luck's sarcastic Gabe = Full House's sarcastic Stephanie

Let's not even get into the PJ/DJ thing.

Keep an eye out for Nickelodeon to make the next move, a sitcom focusing on a suburban family of four, including a generally well-behaved, cap-wearing seven-year-old boy nicknamed after a semi-aquatic rodent.

Will this family-focused strategy get you to watch kids TV channels with your children? Chime in below!

Chime In
Will family shows like 'Good Luck, Charlie' get you to watch kid TV channels?
Chime in now!
    More to Explore
    Demi Lovato Quits 'Sonny With a Chance' - iVillage Demi is still signed to one of Disney's music labels. While it's unclear where Demi ...Is Demi Lovato making the right career move in leaving 'Sonny With a Chance'? MORE
    Will 'Sonny with a Chance' Go on Without Demi Lovato? - iVillage ... or Two and a Half Men minus one man -- but will viewers watch Sonny with a Chance ... It will be interesting to find out (and to see if kids still tune in). Of course ... MORE
    Unblinking Eye Halloween Meatloaf - iVillage Meatloaf is such an ordinary weeknight dinner. But not this one, which makes an extra effort for Halloween night: A row of peeled hard-boiled eggs inside makes each ... MORE
    Demi Lovato Reaches Settlement, Spends Holiday with Family - iVillage use search title|... for emotional and physical issues, the young star made two big strides over ... While they toured together with The Jonas Brothers during the South American leg of their ... MORE
    Advertisement

    'My Best Idea' Clip of the Day

    Advertisement