Welcome to iVillage.com! or Join Now!

Hi, User

Edit Connections

iVillage

Decision Point

Fertility Problems: Should I Have a Tubal Procedure or In Vitro Fertilization?

You may want to have a say in this decision, or you may simply want to follow your doctor's recommendation. Either way, this information will help you understand what your choices are so that you can talk to your doctor about them.

Turn on Accessibility Mode

Fertility Problems: Should I Have a Tubal Procedure or In Vitro Fertilization?

1

Get the
Facts

2

Compare
Options

3

Your
Feelings

4

Your
Decision

5

Quiz
Yourself

6

Your
Summary

Get the facts

Your options

Have surgery on your fallopian tubes.
Have in vitro fertilization.

Key points to remember

Fallopian tube surgery can reverse infertility if a tubal problem is the cause. If you get pregnant after tubal surgery, you shouldn't need more fertility treatment.
In vitro fertilization (IVF) does not reverse infertility. You need to have IVF each time you try to get pregnant.
You may be able to get pregnant sooner after IVF than after surgery.
You'll need surgery if the tubal problem causes a buildup of fluid called a hydrosalpinx. Fluid that drains from a hydrosalpinx into the uterus greatly reduces your chances of getting pregnant, with or without IVF.
It's hard to know if treatment for a tubal problem will work. Your chances of getting pregnant and having a healthy pregnancy depend on how bad the tubal problem is, your age, and whether you or your partner has any other fertility problems.
If you are age 35 or older, your doctor may recommend that you skip the surgery and have IVF. After age 35, the chances of IVF working drop a lot as each year passes. You may not want to spend time having surgery and then waiting to see if you get pregnant.

FAQs

What surgeries are done to fix fallopian tube problems?

There are several types of surgery to fix blocked fallopian tubes. The type of surgery you have will depend on the type of blockage, where it is, and how bad it is. Surgery may be done to:

Remove the blocked part of the tube, clear out scar tissue, or put in a plastic tube to open the blocked area.
Rejoin a fallopian tube that was cut in a tubal ligation.
Remove the diseased part of the tube. This may be done to treat a hydrosalpinx, which is a fluid-blocked fallopian tube that may drain into the uterus. A doctor also may remove fluid, create a drainage hole in the tube, or block the tube's opening to the uterus.

These surgeries are usually done through a small incision (laparoscopically).

What are the risks of fallopian tube surgery?

Fallopian tube surgery may or may not lead to a healthy pregnancy. About 7 to 9 out of 100 women who get pregnant after fallopian tube surgery have an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy, which can be dangerous. This means that 91 to 93 out of 100 women who have the surgery don't have an ectopic pregnancy. These pregnancies usually happen because of tubal damage the women already had before surgery, rather than the surgery itself.²

For women 35 or older, perhaps the greatest risk is the time it takes to recover from surgery and then try to get pregnant. If you want to try only tubal surgery, the sooner you begin, the better. If you are thinking about having IVF with your own eggs, you may want to start IVF as soon as possible, rather than having surgery.

What is IVF?

During in vitro fertilization (IVF), a woman's eggs are mixed with a man's sperm in a lab. The resulting embryo or embryos are then transferred into the uterus. Your doctor can use your eggs and sperm for IVF, or you can try donor eggs or sperm if needed.

Most women begin the IVF process by having daily hormone shots to grow multiple eggs. This is called superovulation. The eggs are then collected, either through a needle guided by ultrasound or laparoscope. The best-quality eggs are fertilized with sperm, and the best embryos are implanted in the uterus. Then you have a series of hormone shots to support the first days of pregnancy.

Some women choose to use their own eggs naturally and not use superovulation.

What can IVF treat?

In vitro fertilization (IVF) was first used for women with no fallopian tubes. Now this procedure is also used to treat couples whose infertility is caused by:

Blocked or diseased fallopian tubes.
Severe endometriosis.
A tubal ligation, or surgery that wasn't able to reverse tubal ligation.
Low sperm counts.
Unexplained infertility that has gone on for a long time.

What are the risks of IVF?

In vitro fertilization (IVF) is emotionally and physically demanding. You need to have several procedures to produce and collect eggs and then to implant embryos. IVF increases the risks of:

Multiple pregnancy. About 35 out of 100 births in the United States that result from methods like IVF produce two or more children.¹ Multiple pregnancies are high-risk for both the mother and the fetuses.
Severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, which can be deadly. This happens in up to 2 out of 100 IVF cycles.² Your doctor can reduce this risk by closely checking your ovaries and hormone levels.

If you choose IVF, talk to your doctor about how to reduce your risk of multiple pregnancy.

Why might your doctor recommend surgery or IVF?

Your doctor might recommend surgery on your fallopian tubes if:

You have a problem that causes fluid to build up in your fallopian tubes.
A problem with your fallopian tubes is your only fertility problem.
You are 34 or younger and are willing to take the time to have surgery, recover, and then see if you can get pregnant.

Your doctor might recommend IVF if:

You have severe tubal damage or disease.
You are 35 or older. You may want to try to get pregnant as soon as you can, rather than wait to recover from surgery and see if you get pregnant. The chances that IVF with your own eggs will work drop a lot the older you get.
You want to get pregnant fairly soon, whatever your age. You may be able to get pregnant sooner after IVF than after surgery.

Compare your options

Compare


What is usually involved?
What are the benefits?
What are the risks and side effects?

Have tubal surgery Have tubal surgery

You stay in the hospital for 2 or 3 days, depending on the surgery.
It takes from a few days to up to 6 weeks to recover, depending on the surgery.

It can help you get pregnant if a problem with your fallopian tubes is your only fertility problem. Up to 60 out of 100 women who have a blockage close to the uterus are able to get pregnant after the procedure.² The chance of pregnancy is lower if the blockage is near the end of the fallopian tube.
If the surgery works, you won't need to have more treatment each time you want to get pregnant.

You may not get pregnant after surgery. Your chances of pregnancy after surgery depend on the type of tubal damage you have.
There is a chance of having an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy after surgery. About 7 to 9 out of 100 women who get pregnant after the surgery have an ectopic pregnancy.²
Surgery involves risks of general anesthesia.
It may take longer to get pregnant than it would with IVF because of the time it takes to recover from surgery.
Your health insurance may not cover fallopian tube surgery for infertility.

Have IVF Have IVF

You have a series of hormone shots to make multiple eggs.
You have a procedure to take the eggs out of your body and another one to implant the fertilized eggs.

It can help you get pregnant. Your chance of getting pregnant depends in part on your age and whether you use your own eggs. Between 30 and 40 women out of 100 who use their own eggs and are younger than age 35 get pregnant with IVF.³ The odds of getting pregnant with your own eggs are much less after age 35. But for women in their late 20s through mid-40s who use donor eggs, the chances of getting pregnant are about 50 out of 100.³
You can avoid having surgery and then waiting to see if you get pregnant.
You might be able to get pregnant sooner with IVF than you can after surgery.

You may not get pregnant. Your chances of pregnancy with IVF depend on how good your eggs are. (Donor eggs may improve your chances).
IVF can lead to having twins or more. Pregnancy with more than one baby is higher-risk.
The process can be hard emotionally and physically.
The hormone shots can sometimes lead to a serious problem that means you have to stop the IVF cycle.
IVF doesn't fix a fertility problem. So you need to do IVF each time you try to get pregnant.
The average cost of one IVF cycle is $10,000 to $15,000 in the United States. Health insurance often doesn't cover IVF.

Personal stories

Are you interested in what others decided to do? Many people have faced this decision. These personal stories may help you decide.

Personal stories about tubal infertility treatment

These stories are based on information gathered from health professionals and consumers. They may be helpful as you make important health decisions.

Since we learned that I have blocked fallopian tubes, we've been going back and forth about what to do. Time is ticking away, so we need to act soon. I've decided that I'm willing to have surgery and keep trying to conceive for a year. My hormone tests tell me that I'm still fertile, and who knows—maybe we could actually have more than one child after fixing the problem. If not, we're considering adopting.

Karen, age 36

I was shocked to learn that my fallopian tubes were so badly damaged by the chlamydia infection I had a few years ago. My doctor says that we can try surgery to repair the tubes, but that my best bet is trying in vitro fertilization. We can't possibly afford in vitro fertilization, and we're lucky that my insurance will cover the surgery, so I'm going to have the surgery and see if it helps.

Marianna, age 26

Now that we're ready to have a child, we're really ready! We don't care what it takes. Our doctor tells us that in vitro fertilization is really our only choice, considering my age. By the time I have my tubes repaired and start trying to get pregnant, I'll be too old to have any other options if that doesn't work. So, we're going to go for it and do the in vitro fertilization. We figure we'll try it three times and hope one of them takes.

Teri, age 39

I'm told that I have a small blockage in one of my fallopian tubes that can be treated without surgery. The doc says she can put a little plastic catheter in my fallopian tube to open up the blockage, and I have a good chance of getting pregnant after that.

Anne, age 30

If you need more information about infertility treatments, see the topic Fertility Problems.

What matters most to you?

Your personal feelings are just as important as the medical facts. Think about what matters most to you in this decision, and show how you feel about the following statements.

Reasons to have surgery

Reasons to have IVF

I want to have surgery and then wait and see if I can get pregnant.

I don't want to take the time to see if surgery will work.

More important

Equally important

More important

I don't want to go through a fertility treatment each time I want to get pregnant.

I want to get pregnant as soon as possible, even if I have to do IVF each time I want to get pregnant.

More important

Equally important

More important

I'm scared of having a bad problem from the hormones in IVF.

I'm not worried about side effects from taking hormones.

More important

Equally important

More important

I don't mind paying for the one-time cost of surgery.

I'm worried about the cost of IVF. I can't afford to have IVF each time I want to get pregnant.

More important

Equally important

More important

My other important reasons:

My other important reasons:

More important

Equally important

More important

Where are you leaning now?

Now that you've thought about the facts and your feelings, you may have a general idea of where you stand on this decision. Show which way you are leaning right now.

Having surgery

Having IVF

Leaning toward

Undecided

Leaning toward

Your summary

Here's a record of your answers. You can use it to talk with your doctor or loved ones about your decision.

Your decision

Next steps

Which way you're leaning

How sure you are

Your comments

Your knowledge of the facts

Key concepts that you understood

Key concepts that may need review

Getting ready to act

Patient choices

What matters to you

Credits and references

Credits

Author	Healthwise Staff
Primary Medical Reviewer	Sarah Marshall, MD - Family Medicine
Specialist Medical Reviewer	Femi Olatunbosun, MB, FRCSC - Obstetrics and Gynecology

References

Citations

Speroff L, Fritz MA (2005). Assisted reproductive technologies. In Clinical Gynecologic Endocrinology and Infertility, 7th ed., pp. 1216–1274. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Al-Inany H (2005). Female infertility, search date April 2004. Online version of BMJ Clinical Evidence. Also available online: http://www.clinicalevidence.com.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (2008). 2006 Assisted Reproductive Technology Success Rates: National Summary and Fertility Clinic Reports. Available online: http://www.cdc.gov/ART/ART2006/508PDF/2006ART.pdf.

Fertility Problems: Should I Have a Tubal Procedure or In Vitro Fertilization?

You can use it to talk with your doctor or loved ones about your decision.

Get the facts
Compare your options
What matters most to you?
Where are you leaning now?
What else do you need to make your decision?

1. Get the Facts

Your options

Have surgery on your fallopian tubes.
Have in vitro fertilization.

Key points to remember

Fallopian tube surgery can reverse infertility if a tubal problem is the cause. If you get pregnant after tubal surgery, you shouldn't need more fertility treatment.
In vitro fertilization (IVF) does not reverse infertility. You need to have IVF each time you try to get pregnant.
You may be able to get pregnant sooner after IVF than after surgery.
You'll need surgery if the tubal problem causes a buildup of fluid called a hydrosalpinx. Fluid that drains from a hydrosalpinx into the uterus greatly reduces your chances of getting pregnant, with or without IVF.
It's hard to know if treatment for a tubal problem will work. Your chances of getting pregnant and having a healthy pregnancy depend on how bad the tubal problem is, your age, and whether you or your partner has any other fertility problems.
If you are age 35 or older, your doctor may recommend that you skip the surgery and have IVF. After age 35, the chances of IVF working drop a lot as each year passes. You may not want to spend time having surgery and then waiting to see if you get pregnant.

FAQs

What surgeries are done to fix fallopian tube problems?

There are several types of surgery to fix blocked fallopian tubes. The type of surgery you have will depend on the type of blockage, where it is, and how bad it is. Surgery may be done to:

Remove the blocked part of the tube, clear out scar tissue, or put in a plastic tube to open the blocked area.
Rejoin a fallopian tube that was cut in a tubal ligation.
Remove the diseased part of the tube. This may be done to treat a hydrosalpinx, which is a fluid-blocked fallopian tube that may drain into the uterus. A doctor also may remove fluid, create a drainage hole in the tube, or block the tube's opening to the uterus.

These surgeries are usually done through a small incision (laparoscopically).

What are the risks of fallopian tube surgery?

Fallopian tube surgery may or may not lead to a healthy pregnancy. About 7 to 9 out of 100 women who get pregnant after fallopian tube surgery have an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy, which can be dangerous. This means that 91 to 93 out of 100 women who have the surgery don't have an ectopic pregnancy. These pregnancies usually happen because of tubal damage the women already had before surgery, rather than the surgery itself.²

For women 35 or older, perhaps the greatest risk is the time it takes to recover from surgery and then try to get pregnant. If you want to try only tubal surgery, the sooner you begin, the better. If you are thinking about having IVF with your own eggs, you may want to start IVF as soon as possible, rather than having surgery.

What is IVF?

During in vitro fertilization (IVF), a woman's eggs are mixed with a man's sperm in a lab. The resulting embryo or embryos are then transferred into the uterus. Your doctor can use your eggs and sperm for IVF, or you can try donor eggs or sperm if needed.

Most women begin the IVF process by having daily hormone shots to grow multiple eggs. This is called superovulation. The eggs are then collected, either through a needle guided by ultrasound or laparoscope. The best-quality eggs are fertilized with sperm, and the best embryos are implanted in the uterus. Then you have a series of hormone shots to support the first days of pregnancy.

Some women choose to use their own eggs naturally and not use superovulation.

What can IVF treat?

In vitro fertilization (IVF) was first used for women with no fallopian tubes. Now this procedure is also used to treat couples whose infertility is caused by:

Blocked or diseased fallopian tubes.
Severe endometriosis.
A tubal ligation, or surgery that wasn't able to reverse tubal ligation.
Low sperm counts.
Unexplained infertility that has gone on for a long time.

What are the risks of IVF?

In vitro fertilization (IVF) is emotionally and physically demanding. You need to have several procedures to produce and collect eggs and then to implant embryos. IVF increases the risks of:

Multiple pregnancy. About 35 out of 100 births in the United States that result from methods like IVF produce two or more children.¹ Multiple pregnancies are high-risk for both the mother and the fetuses.
Severe ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome, which can be deadly. This happens in up to 2 out of 100 IVF cycles.² Your doctor can reduce this risk by closely checking your ovaries and hormone levels.

If you choose IVF, talk to your doctor about how to reduce your risk of multiple pregnancy.

Why might your doctor recommend surgery or IVF?

Your doctor might recommend surgery on your fallopian tubes if:

You have a problem that causes fluid to build up in your fallopian tubes.
A problem with your fallopian tubes is your only fertility problem.
You are 34 or younger and are willing to take the time to have surgery, recover, and then see if you can get pregnant.

Your doctor might recommend IVF if:

You have severe tubal damage or disease.
You are 35 or older. You may want to try to get pregnant as soon as you can, rather than wait to recover from surgery and see if you get pregnant. The chances that IVF with your own eggs will work drop a lot the older you get.
You want to get pregnant fairly soon, whatever your age. You may be able to get pregnant sooner after IVF than after surgery.

2. Compare your options

	Have tubal surgery	Have IVF
What is usually involved?	You stay in the hospital for 2 or 3 days, depending on the surgery. It takes from a few days to up to 6 weeks to recover, depending on the surgery.	You have a series of hormone shots to make multiple eggs. You have a procedure to take the eggs out of your body and another one to implant the fertilized eggs.
What are the benefits?	It can help you get pregnant if a problem with your fallopian tubes is your only fertility problem. Up to 60 out of 100 women who have a blockage close to the uterus are able to get pregnant after the procedure.² The chance of pregnancy is lower if the blockage is near the end of the fallopian tube. If the surgery works, you won't need to have more treatment each time you want to get pregnant.	It can help you get pregnant. Your chance of getting pregnant depends in part on your age and whether you use your own eggs. Between 30 and 40 women out of 100 who use their own eggs and are younger than age 35 get pregnant with IVF.³ The odds of getting pregnant with your own eggs are much less after age 35. But for women in their late 20s through mid-40s who use donor eggs, the chances of getting pregnant are about 50 out of 100.³ You can avoid having surgery and then waiting to see if you get pregnant. You might be able to get pregnant sooner with IVF than you can after surgery.
What are the risks and side effects?	You may not get pregnant after surgery. Your chances of pregnancy after surgery depend on the type of tubal damage you have. There is a chance of having an ectopic (tubal) pregnancy after surgery. About 7 to 9 out of 100 women who get pregnant after the surgery have an ectopic pregnancy.² Surgery involves risks of general anesthesia. It may take longer to get pregnant than it would with IVF because of the time it takes to recover from surgery. Your health insurance may not cover fallopian tube surgery for infertility.	You may not get pregnant. Your chances of pregnancy with IVF depend on how good your eggs are. (Donor eggs may improve your chances). IVF can lead to having twins or more. Pregnancy with more than one baby is higher-risk. The process can be hard emotionally and physically. The hormone shots can sometimes lead to a serious problem that means you have to stop the IVF cycle. IVF doesn't fix a fertility problem. So you need to do IVF each time you try to get pregnant. The average cost of one IVF cycle is $10,000 to $15,000 in the United States. Health insurance often doesn't cover IVF.

Personal stories

Are you interested in what others decided to do? Many people have faced this decision. These personal stories may help you decide.

If you need more information about infertility treatments, see the topic Fertility Problems.

Personal stories about tubal infertility treatment

These stories are based on information gathered from health professionals and consumers. They may be helpful as you make important health decisions.

"Since we learned that I have blocked fallopian tubes, we've been going back and forth about what to do. Time is ticking away, so we need to act soon. I've decided that I'm willing to have surgery and keep trying to conceive for a year. My hormone tests tell me that I'm still fertile, and who knows—maybe we could actually have more than one child after fixing the problem. If not, we're considering adopting."

— Karen, age 36

"I was shocked to learn that my fallopian tubes were so badly damaged by the chlamydia infection I had a few years ago. My doctor says that we can try surgery to repair the tubes, but that my best bet is trying in vitro fertilization. We can't possibly afford in vitro fertilization, and we're lucky that my insurance will cover the surgery, so I'm going to have the surgery and see if it helps."

— Marianna, age 26

"Now that we're ready to have a child, we're really ready! We don't care what it takes. Our doctor tells us that in vitro fertilization is really our only choice, considering my age. By the time I have my tubes repaired and start trying to get pregnant, I'll be too old to have any other options if that doesn't work. So, we're going to go for it and do the in vitro fertilization. We figure we'll try it three times and hope one of them takes."

— Teri, age 39

"I'm told that I have a small blockage in one of my fallopian tubes that can be treated without surgery. The doc says she can put a little plastic catheter in my fallopian tube to open up the blockage, and I have a good chance of getting pregnant after that."

— Anne, age 30

3. What matters most to you?

Your personal feelings are just as important as the medical facts. Think about what matters most to you in this decision, and show how you feel about the following statements.

Reasons to have surgery

Reasons to have IVF

I want to have surgery and then wait and see if I can get pregnant.

I don't want to take the time to see if surgery will work.

More important

Equally important

More important

I don't want to go through a fertility treatment each time I want to get pregnant.

I want to get pregnant as soon as possible, even if I have to do IVF each time I want to get pregnant.

More important

Equally important

More important

I'm scared of having a bad problem from the hormones in IVF.

I'm not worried about side effects from taking hormones.

More important

Equally important

More important

I don't mind paying for the one-time cost of surgery.

I'm worried about the cost of IVF. I can't afford to have IVF each time I want to get pregnant.

More important

Equally important

More important

My other important reasons:

My other important reasons:

More important

Equally important

More important

4. Where are you leaning now?

Now that you've thought about the facts and your feelings, you may have a general idea of where you stand on this decision. Show which way you are leaning right now.

Having surgery

Having IVF

Leaning toward

Undecided

Leaning toward

Credits

Author	Healthwise Staff
Primary Medical Reviewer	Sarah Marshall, MD - Family Medicine
Specialist Medical Reviewer	Femi Olatunbosun, MB, FRCSC - Obstetrics and Gynecology

References

Citations

Speroff L, Fritz MA (2005). Assisted reproductive technologies. In Clinical Gynecologic Endocrinology and Infertility, 7th ed., pp. 1216–1274. Philadelphia: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins.
Al-Inany H (2005). Female infertility, search date April 2004. Online version of BMJ Clinical Evidence. Also available online: http://www.clinicalevidence.com.
Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, American Society for Reproductive Medicine, Society for Assisted Reproductive Technology (2008). 2006 Assisted Reproductive Technology Success Rates: National Summary and Fertility Clinic Reports. Available online: http://www.cdc.gov/ART/ART2006/508PDF/2006ART.pdf.

Note: The "printer friendly" document will not contain all the information available in the online document some Information (e.g. cross-references to other topics, definitions or medical illustrations) is only available in the online version.

Top of Page

Last Updated:March 19, 2010

Author:Healthwise Staff

Medical Review:Sarah Marshall, MD - Family Medicine & Femi Olatunbosun, MB, FRCSC - Obstetrics and Gynecology

© 1995-2011 Healthwise, Incorporated. Healthwise, Healthwise for every health decision, and the Healthwise logo are trademarks of Healthwise, Incorporated. This information does not replace the advice of a doctor. Healthwise, Incorporated disclaims any warranty or liability for your use of this information. Your use of this information means that you agree to the Terms of Use. How this information was developed to help you make better health decisions.

iVillage RSS Feed

Care Circle

It Seems That You Are Not Logged In...

OR

Log In
Help

Welcome to Care Circle, an exclusive tool to help you take care of yourself and your loved ones. Here's how it works:

Create profiles for yourself and your loved ones.
Select the topics and conditions that interest each of you.
Get customized news updates, original content, tools, and expert advice for each Care Circle member delivered directly to your personalized homepage.

The information you input is strictly private; you choose who has access to your Care Circle.

Adding Someone
Saving Content
Adding Additional Topics & Conditions
Deleting Topics & Conditions

How do I add myself or someone else to my care circle?

Click on "Add someone." Fill out the short profile. Choose an avatar. Select the topics and conditions that interest this person from the pulldown menu. You can select as many as you want, but you must choose at least one. Click on "Add Someone" again. You should start getting updates immediately.

How do I save content to my Care Circle?

Click on "Manage My Care Circle." Select the tab of the person for whom you're saving content. Put your cursor over the piece of content that you want to save; a disk icon will appear in the righthand corner. Click on the disk and the piece of content will be moved to a save folder.

How do I add additional topics and conditions for someone in my Care Circle?

Click on "Manage My Care Circle." Select the tab for the person whose preferences you'd like to update. Under "Add More to Follow," select additional topics and conditions.

How do I delete topics and conditions for someone in my Care Circle?

Click on "Manage My Care Circle." Select the tab for the person whose preferences you'd like to update. Under "Follows," scroll over the topic or condition you want to delete. An "X" should appear on the righthand side. Click on the "X" and the topic or condition will be deleted from the list.

News Article
Many Still Tanning, Despite Dangers, Survey Finds
News Article
Physical Education Is Good for Kids' Grades, Study Finds
News Article
Keep Food Safety in Mind This Memorial Day Weekend
News Article
Exercise Helps Older Adults Stay Fit
News Article
Travel to High Altitudes Tied to Crohn's, Colitis Flare-Ups
News Article
The Science of Tasty Tomatoes Lies in the Chemicals