THE BACHELOR, season 13 (2009): Account executive and single dad Jason Mesnick first appeared on The Bachelorette in pursuit of DeAnna Pappas, who spurned his marriage proposal. Scooped up to star in a new season of The Bachelor, Jason then shocked fans when he committed the biggest flip-flop in the show's history. After proposing to former Dallas Cowboys cheerleader Melissa Rycroft, he dumped her (while cameras rolled) during the After the Final Rose episode hosted by Chris Harrison. Jaws were still on the floor when, moments later, Jason asked runner-up Molly Malaney for a second chance. Jason and Molly wed during a happy (rain-soaked) ceremony that aired on ABC in 2010, and the two are expecting a baby due next March. Rycroft, meanwhile, also ended up with the fairy-tale ending she deserved when she married Tye Strickland in 2009, and the two welcomed baby girl Ava Grace last February.