Why We Love Him: He may no longer be playing the field, but we can still swoon over Jay Cutler's big blue eyes, right? After a whirlwind romance with reality starlet Kristin Cavallari, the two finally made it official -- after calling off the engagement once before -- and welcomed a baby boy, Camden, in August 2012. Tall and handsome, the quarterback for "Da Bears" also has brains. This good ol' Midwestern guy graduated from Vanderbilt University with a bachelor's degree in human and organizational development. Impressive!