THE BACHELORETTE, season 5 (2009): Interior designer Jillian Harris was sent home by Jason Mesnick during The Bachelor, season 13. But the bubbly Canadian had better luck as star of her own Bachelorette season. She ultimately fielded three marriage proposals -- from Ed Swiderski, Kiptyn Locke and Reid Rosenthal (who made a surprise reappearance in the finale, despite being rejected after the hometown dates). Jillian chose Ed, and they moved to Chicago to start planning a wedding. But, like many before them, their romance headed south, and they called it quits July 2010.