About Him: Sure, Fatone is a relatively big guy, but his boy-band and Broadway days conditioned him for the dance floor. He may have never walked away with a Mirror Ball, but he's come close -- he was the season 4 runner-up, coming in behind Apolo Anton Ohno.
Why He Was Cut: The battle of the boy banders (Fatone vs. Drew Lachey) would have been a fun one to watch! Sadly, Fatone was eliminated after a lackluster jive on Monday, which earned him 22.5 points and a spot in a three-way tie for seventh place. The judges had agreed that the performance had many technical flaws, but the audience still booed after hearing that Fatone was out. "We had a great time. People said I was fun and that’s all that matters," he said, smiling.