Brett Ratner disagrees, as the director, who has worked with Madge on her "Beautiful Stranger" video and has just done Miley's "7 Things" vid, says these ladies have a lot in common.
"She turns it on," the filmmaker told E! News, of Hannah Montana. "A lot like Madonna."
"Where a lot of other artists are nervous or they're primping, you know, Madonna walks on and is casual; cameras are on her and then all of the sudden, wow!" Brett said. "Same thing with Miley. She's hanging out, she's telling the jokes, she's laughing, she's signing an autograph. Camera goes on her and she was just unbelievable."
I'm sure Miley's dad is thrilled by the comparison -- how long before the good Christian girl (remember when Madonna was one?) is causing a religious uproar?