Natural Makeup Look for Fair Skinned Redheads - Dilemma of the Week

I am a redhead with very pale skin. I always leave the makeup counters looking way too made up; never finding that "natural" look I crave. Help?

You are so lucky to have the natural, even regal, coloring admired by so many -- in Renaissance art, in romance novels, even in to today's Hollywood (Nicole Kidman, anyone?). Celebrate it! You have naturally vibrant coloring, so the intensity of contrasting makeup colors is something darker-skinned Latin, South Asian, and African beauties can wear so well, but just won't wear well with your fair complexion.

Renaissance artist Sandro Botticelli got it right with his paintings of delicately featured, wonderful females with flowing red hair and the most sensitive of demeanors; could anyone have a better beauty role model? I think not. Here's how to enhance your natural radiance without looking too made up:

  • For lips and cheeks, I love the look of pale blue-pinks on redheads, or the sheerest golden amber hues.
  • For eyes, try the subtlety of a shimmery gold, copper, or khaki.
  • For the most natural look stay away from oranges and orange-reds (so harsh); browns (too muddy) and purples (too freakish).
  • For lining eyes, choose a muted charcoal gray/black. Line the top of the eyes only for day, but for night, try smudging a tiny bit under the outer corners for a bit of mystery.
  • For eyelashes, curl them, then apply a light- to medium-brown tinted mascara. Wipe the wand first to prevent clumps.
  • For eyebrows, do not darken them. If you do need to fill them in, choose a color a shade lighter than your hair. Dark eyebrows on your fair complexion look startlingly inappropriate.

Recommended Products:

Shu Uemura Glow On Blush in Pink or Amber
These are the sheerest, most angelic inspired colors around, available in pearl, matte and sheer.
Price: $22
Available: (888) 540-8181, Shu Uemura, Sephora,

Delux Beauty Flush Stick in Berry
My personal fave, this gel-like, blendable blush glides on like velvet and gives a wonderful, sheer, watercolor-like flush to the cheeks.
Price: $30
Available: Sephora,

M.A.C Eye Shadow
I'm a fan. Choose Goldmine for a translucent, satiny golden sheen; Mythology for a translucent, pinkish-amber sheen; and Soba for a shimmery golden, khaki sheen.
Price: $12.50 each
Available: (800) 387-6707, M.A.C boutiques and counters,,

Estée Lauder Go Wink Liquid Eyeshadow
Gives sparkly highlights with translucent color; really stays put. (Lately, I'm living in Pink Wink.)
Price: $16
Available: Department stores, Esté,

Bobbi Brown Lip Stain in Bare or Beige
Just a hint of Botticelli-inspired colors.
Available: Department stores,,

Chanel Hydracaresse Lipstick in Pink Sugar
Soft, subtle, and so flattering for fair complexions.
Price: $21.50
Available: Department stores,,

Dilemma of the Week Main Page >>>

Like this? Want more?
Connect with Us
Follow Our Pins

Yummy recipes, DIY projects, home decor, fashion and more curated by iVillage staffers.

Follow Our Tweets

The very dirty truth about fashion internships... DUN DUN @srslytheshow

On Instagram

Behind-the-scenes pics from iVillage.

Best of the Web