The moment that made Simpson a household name wasn't a sexy photo shoot or a hit song: It was real-life footage of her confusing tuna and chicken on the premiere of Newlyweds. "Is this chicken, what I have, or is this fish?" she asked then-husband Nick Lachey as she ate a bowl of tuna salad. "I know it's tuna, but it says chicken... by the sea." Lachey patiently explained that Chicken of the Sea was a brand name, but there were plenty of other Simpson gaffes to come: She refused buffalo wings because "I don't eat buffalo," swore that platypus is correctly pronounced "plat-a-ma-pus", and wondered out loud if there are "maids for, like, celebrities."