VBAC: Is VBAC required?

I'm due to have my second child in three weeks. My first was delivered by cesarean, due to breech position. The surgery went very well and my recovery was very fast and easy. I am frightened to have a VBAC. I'd prefer to have a repeat cesarean, but I feel silly about requesting the surgery when there is no medical reason for it. Is VBAC required?

Question:
ABOUT THE EXPERT

Peg Plumbo CNM

Peg Plumbo has been a certified nurse-midwife (CNM) since 1976. She has assisted at over 1,000 births and currently teaches in the... Read more

It is very normal for you to have major fears and apprehensions. When you gave birth previously, the control was taken entirely out of your hands. Now it has been returned to you and you are faced with some very big decisions.

Though it is doubtful that a physician would require that you have a VBAC, they would/should strongly recommend it. Vaginal delivery is safer for the baby and for the mother.

Uterine rupture is a very uncommon event. In one major study of 8000 women, this complication occurred in 1.5 percent of VBAC births compared to 0.5 percent for vaginal delivery. About two-thirds of all women who plan a VBAC can expect to give birth vaginally. Most are very happy that they did.

I would encourage you to express your fears to your obstetrician. Even if you decide to opt for a cesarean, consider a trial of labor. This helps the baby accommodate to the outside world by squeezing the fluids out of his lungs and also benefits the contractility of the uterus.

Everything will work out for the best if you have faith in your body and benefit from the supportive skilled care of your doctor.

Answer:
Chime In
Chime in now!
    More to Explore
    Exclusively pumping breastmilk What are the Benefits of Feeding Expressed Milk? Providing expressed breastmilk is a wonderful choice when breastfeeding does not work out. There are many advantages to providing breastmilk over formula. The risks of f MORE
    How long does alcohol remain in breastmilk? Alcohol does pass freely into breastmilk, though in small amounts and in short duration. Alcohol is considered compatible with breastfeeding by the American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Drugs and Chemicals and Human Milk. Alcohol will le MORE
    Homebirth 101 Is homebirth safe? Safety has been held up as the reason why all women should give birth in the hospital. This is despite the fact that no data support the contention that homebirth holds any excess risk provided: MORE
    Breast milk: Increasing supply There are no specific foods to eat that will stimulate production of breast milk, but there are things that can help with milk production. More important than what you eat is how your baby eats. When a baby is properly positioned, well-attached and su MORE
    The Most Intriguing Breastfeeding Scandals After waiting more than two hours to appear before a judge (over a little boating ticket), Michigan mama Natalie Hegedus made the bold decision to feed her sick, hungry five-month-old right there in the courtroom. Despite the fact that her breasts wer MORE
    Need Advice?
    Get answers from iVillage experts and other moms just like you!
    ASK YOUR QUESTION
    Question Details
    Subject
    1. Pick a subject:
    Advertisement
    Connect with 1,039,394 members just like you
    Share your knowledge, ask questions.
    Advertisement