Will he change for me?

Dear Sherry,

I need some help. I've been dating this guy for almost 11 months. I love everything about him, except that he smokes dope. I have told him that I do not approve. At first, he told me that he would probably never quit. Then recently he quit, but restarted after about a month of being clean. Is it wrong to ask him to stop, or make him choose between his paraphernalia and me? And if he agrees to stop -- stop for good -- will I be able to trust him to not go behind my back? I don't want anything to do with his smoking and don't want it anywhere around me, but I have a hard time seeing myself without him. I care for him very deeply. Please help me. I am lost and confused about what to do. -- Lady

Question:
ABOUT THE EXPERT

Sherry Amatenstein

Sherry is the author of The Q&A Dating Book and Love Lessons from Bad Breakups. She has taught dating seminars, appeared as an expert... Read more

Dear Lady,

Congratulations for not reacting in ostrich-like fashion to your boyfriend's habit. When you love someone, the natural inclination is to tell yourself his problem will somehow just go away. The reality is quite the opposite. It's much better you face this mess now than wait until after you're married.

Will he stop smoking dope for your sake? No, but that doesn't make him a bad person or mean that he doesn't want to make you happy. No one can stop doing something for someone else's sake. He has to be committed to giving up dope because that's something he wants and needs to do. Otherwise his efforts will be half-hearted and, most likely, ineffectual. He'll resent you for being the cause of his discomfort and yes, he might start smoking behind your back.

Don't give him an ultimatum. Rather, tell him that you love him, but can't be with someone who uses drugs. If he wants to quit for himself, you'll do everything possible to support his efforts, but you DON'T want him to quit for you. If he wants to keep smoking, you bear him no ill will, but you need to let him go.

Lady, be aware that if someone is in trouble with drugs, they'll be more than willing to lie. He might tell you he's quitting, but you have to deduce whether or not he's sincere. (One clue: Would he willing to join a 12-step program?)

In the end, breaking up with someone you love is hard -- but, ultimately, not as hard as dating a druggie.

Answer:
Chime In
Chime in now!
    More to Explore
    Normal Menstrual Cycle - iVillage Sleep; Sex after Pregnancy; Losing the Baby Weight; Work & Family; Money; Holidays & Travel ... Stress or very hard exercise also can change your cycle. Pregnancy is the most ... MORE
    How soon after birth will your period return? Women who don't breastfeed find that their cycles resume very quickly -- as early as four to ten weeks after childbirth. If, however, you meet the following three criteria, then your chances of ovulating are only about two percent: MORE
    Calculating the Fertile Period - iVillage Get Pregnant Faster Ovulation Calendar; See all Tools ... is that the guy is supposed to arrive early for a date ... you to use the charts effectively, your menstrual cycles ... MORE
    How Do I Calculate My Menstrual Cycle? - iVillage You can select as many as you want, but you must choose at least one. Clickon ... Select the tab of the person for whom you're saving content. Put your cursor over the ... MORE
    Delayed Period: Are You Pregnant? - iVillage Women who are very regular cyclers and who are having unprotected intercourse on a regularbasis and then are suddenly one week late for a period, in my experience ... MORE
    Delayed Period: Could Your Period Be Late Due to Stress? The role of common, everyday stress in delaying menses is perhaps overstated. Just remember all those periods during the big exam or on that trip to Europe or on your wedding day! Of course, some women are more sensitive to stress than others, but it MORE
    Need Advice?
    Get answers from iVillage experts and other moms just like you!
    ASK YOUR QUESTION
    Question Details
    Subject
    1. Pick a subject:
    Advertisement
    Connect with 1,039,394 members just like you
    Share your knowledge, ask questions.
    Advertisement